October 24, 2011

Nina Berman at Occupy Wall Street: Magnetism on the Upper West Side

If the Occupy Wall Street movement has been born out of alienation and deep political cynicism, this image is a hopeful and welcome sight. I can’t speak for the father whose expression is steeped in complexity, but the gaze of his son– captivated by the protesters going by on this street in the Upper West Side on Friday – has the look of an education. (If there was any trepidation, by the way, you’d expect the father would be reaching out to hold onto his son. Yet, even with the police presence, these two are calm and engaged witnesses.)

I wouldn’t have picked up on this seeing the photo from afar, but Nina elaborated how this march was almost devoid of protest signs. Her thought was that, 0ut in the neighborhoods – in contrast to the scene at Zuccotti Park – this expression of activism was for residents by residents. It’s about taking a stand, of course, but in the midst of fellow New Yorkers, it’s as much about the social imperative of any movement — about bonding and collective identity and breaking through the bubble.

The second photo couldn’t offer a more extreme contrast, especially as far as the boys are concerned. As a side glance from the march, this billboard for MasterCard – not to mention the woman on her cell phone– mirrors the best in cultural opiates, leaving us to ponder also how much OWS, creating it’s own brand, might be a game changer.

PHOTOGRAPHS © Nina Berman/Noor.

See Bag’s full OWS coverage here.

Post By

Nina Berman
See other posts by Nina here.

The Big Picture

Follow us on Instagram (@readingthepictures) and Twitter (@readingthepix), and


A curated collection of pieces related to our most-popular subject matter.


Comments Powered by Disqus